Module Descriptors
THE MIRROR UNIVERSE AND RELATIONAL ONTOLOGY
PHIL70307
Key Facts
Digital, Technology, Innovation and Business
Level 7
40 credits
Contact
Leader: David Webb
Hours of Study
Scheduled Learning and Teaching Activities: 26
Independent Study Hours: 374
Total Learning Hours: 400
Pattern of Delivery
  • Occurrence A, Stoke Campus, PG Semester 1
Sites
  • Stoke Campus
Assessment
  • Coursework Essay - 5000 word count weighted at 60%
  • Coursework (e.g. critical analysis - 1500 word count weighted at 30%
  • Discussion Board Contribution - 1000 word count weighted at 10%
Module Details
MODULE LEARNING OUTCOMES
1. Describe and evaluate philosophical and scientific paradigms of the natural universe
2. Explain what is involved in a scientific and philosophical speculative theory.
3. Engage critically in discussions relating to cosmological paradigms.
4. Think and communicate critically and with clarity about complex problems regarding the natural universe.
MODULE ADDITIONAL ASSESSMENT DETAILS
Assessment 1. Learning Outcomes 1, 2, 3.

The coursework essay is the main summative assessment. Students will have the option of formulating their own essay question to address a problem relevant to or arising from the material covered in the module and will be expected to compose a well researched, evidenced, and coherently argued essay.

Assessment 2. Learning Outcomes 1, 2, 3.

This assessment will be formative. Students will be required to undertake a shorter task, such as a critical analysis of a passage from a text set by the module tutor.

Assessment 3. Learning Outcome 4.

The discussion board is a vital part of the learning experience for all students. In addition to requiring students to articulate their understanding of the problems addressed by the module, it provides an opportunity for tutor-student and peer to peer feedback. The criteria against which discussion board contributions will be assessed are: regularity, engagement with others, relevance. Full details are provided in the Module Handbooks and in the Blackboard space for the module.
MODULE INDICATIVE CONTENT
The relation between humankind and the universe can be seen as the ecological question writ large. Michel Serres asks in The Natural Contract, ‘Do we live within the walls of our cities or under the starry dome?’ This module explores questions of nature on a cosmic scale, existence and becoming in terms of relations.

Leibniz proposed a model of the cosmos in terms of mirrors; since, he reasoned, each individual entity affects and is affected by every other in existence to some degree, each part is a reflection of the whole, everything is related. In this light, the question of the relationship between the local and the global takes on a maximal aspect.

The module will treat subsequent variations of Leibniz’ relational ontology: e.g. A.N. Whitehead’s Process Philosophy, which he also referred to as a Cosmology; the concept of the Chaosmos as found in Gilles Deleuze’s work; Michel Serres’ ‘percolating’ time and space. The theme of ‘world memory’ within these frameworks conjoins with the extension of the theme in the module on Information and Communication. Students will be challenged to deliberate on profound questions of being and becoming inherent in these models: e.g. is it coherent to consider ‘process’ as existentially more fundamental than ‘object’, or to conceive ‘difference in itself’ as prior to difference between given terms? Consideration will be given to correspondences between scientific and philosophical models: e.g. from the Leibniz-Clarke correspondence up to contemporary variations such as Loop Quantum Gravity and Holographic models. The aim is to address critically the relationship between humankind and nature at an ontological level.
WEB DESCRIPTOR
‘Do we live within the walls of our cities or under the starry dome?’ (Michel Serres, The Natural Contract). Are we citizens of the world or the universe as a whole? The module ‘The Mirror Universe and Relational Ontology’ explores a wide variety of responses to this question and so many which feed into it: ‘in what ways are the local and the global connected?’; ‘what is the most basic stuff of space and time?’; ‘if the universe is ‘winding down’, what implications are there for the long-term future of our species?’; ‘is everything in the cosmos connected to everything else?’. The module offers an overview of responses to these questions, drawn from philosophical theories, both established and more recent, such as those of Michel Serres and A.N. Whitehead, and from classical and contemporary scientific theoretical work.
MODULE LEARNING STRATEGIES
The module will be entirely Distance Learning. It will be delivered primarily via Blackboard, with additional use made of Teams and other platforms where appropriate. Each week the module tutor will provide reading and/or other material for students to address, tutor notes, and usually supplementary guidance in the form of a video or audio file. Students will be expected to read the texts set week by week, watch or listen to any supplementary material, undertake any tasks proposed by the tutor, and engage with the Discussion Board designated for the module. The emphasis will be on understanding key ideas and connecting them with real world problems. In addition to the Discussion Board, students will complete elements of formative assessment, and where appropriate these will contribute to a collective set of student-generated resources for the module (e.g. book reviews, collections of source material, analyses of significant passages of text) in order to encourage a sense of collective learning through research.
MODULE TEXTS
Barad, Karen Meeting the Universe Half-Way: Quantum Physics and the Entanglement of Matter and Meaning. Duke University Press, 2007.

Bealieu, A ‘Introduction to Deleuze's Cosmological Sensibility’. Filosofiâ i Kosmologiâ, Volume 16,¿Number 1, 2016, pp.¿199-210(12).

Deleuze, G Difference and Repetition. Continuum 2004.

Kim-Chi Mercier, Lucie ‘Michel Serres’s Leibnizian Structuralism’. Angelaki 24 (6) 2019.

Leibniz, GW The Leibniz-Clarke Correspondence. Hackett Publishing, 1977.

Philosophical Essays. Hackett Publishing, 1989.

Martignon L ‘Information Theory’. International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences, 2001, pp.7476-7480.

McHenry, Leemon The Event Universe: the Revisionary Metaphysics of Alfred North Whitehead. Edinburgh University Press, 2015.

Roberts, T ‘From Things to Events: Whitehead and the Materiality of Process’. Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, Vol 32, 6, 2014.

Serres, M The Incandescent. Bloomsbury 2018.

Whitehead, A N Process and Reality. Macmillan, 1979.

Selected papers from the journal: Philosophy and Cosmology.

Selected papers from the journal: Process Studies.
MODULE RESOURCES
Blackboard
Digital Services
Library